I've just finished "Jim and Casper Go to Church," a book written by Jim Henderson (a christian) and Matt Casper (an atheist) based on their experience visiting churches all over the country. The premise of the book is to record Casper's thoughts and reactions as to how we "do church" from an objective point of view. A truly compelling and thought-provoking book, I can't help but contemplate my own views of the church and my own decisions.
It has been seven months since I have regularly attended any formal organized church-- something I never really thought I would have the guts to say aloud, let alone do. I have developed a lifestyle in which I am willing to work on Sundays. I've entered into a place where everything feels a lot looser, I feel much more free to breathe as the box doesn't seem quite as small. I do occasionally attend a worship gathering and it often feels very refreshing to be able to sing loud and dance and listen to someone else for a little while and to watch people as they pour out their souls in this one particular manner. It has been interesting to see how after distancing myself from this monotonous friend for a while, things feel a little different. The distance has allowed me to forgive many things, but I think it has also taught me to release some expectations as well. I'm not sure I really see the church as we usually do it these days as necessarily always an encouragement to follow the ways that Jesus called us to.
Casper makes an astute observation: Even though each church Jim and Casper attended had all sorts of distinctions, the order of the "service" was always the same. Call to worship. Singing. Ask for money. Sermon. And he asks this simple question: "Is this what Jesus told you to do?" He wants to know if Jesus was calling us to get together on Sunday and go through these motions-- was this really his main concern?
All my life I have gone to church. There were very few Sundays before I turned 19 that I did not attend a church service-- non-attendance was
never voluntary. The only justification was sickness, or vacation. It was a regimented as family dinners. You just don't miss. Why? Now that I think about it, I don't really know. I suppose it was this mandate that we never abandon the faith. That, even though often times getting in the car and driving to church and putting on the expected smile felt strangely familiar to a visit to the Dentists' office, being a real christian meant endurance, faithfulness. It meant acting like being rejected, ignored, and, well, hurt, didn't really hurt. Stuffing it down and doing a good job of being "forgiving" for the sake of "unity."
A few months ago, I did a painting about what chuech means to me. While I was working, I asked a friend, "What comes to mind when you think of church?" Her response,
Jesus and people, sort of melted in awkwardness when I stated my response to the same question as
facades and lies. I don't mean to be cynical here, but honest. I wonder, as I write this, if the problem I have with the entity of church is the seeming lack of honesty. Everything is hidden below layers of God knows what. Appearance. We are as caught up in our own plastic surgery as Hollywood. It's just a different kind of Hollywood.
As I continue to move toward what's next for me at home in Colorado, something almost constantly on my mind is the question of where will I find the community I need and long for. There seems to be some (and rightly so) expectation by some that I will return to the Baptist church I was attending before, especially as they work very hard to revive the college ministry that has seemed to collapse in the past year or so. A friend or two fills me in on the progress and I get mass emails chronically their progress. Plans for mentorship programs, missions opportunities, study nights and family dinners in the works. Discussions about how to offer something unique that the 500 other ministries on campus do not offer.
To be really honest, it sounds like the trajectory is headed in a good direction, but I can't help but wonder how it will all really work out. What will really come of it. And the biggest question of all-- do I want to be a part of it? Where is my place?
When it comes down to it, church involvement can easily become just one more thing I do to make myself feel good. I think this time away has really broken me of any dependency upon church attendance for the sake of security. I could care less about completing the spiritual checklist for acceptance. But here is the thing I have learned-- I need people to be around me who are pursuing the kingdom and who are going to be encouraging me to do the same. I suppose my question and its corresponding fear is where do I find a group of people with the objective of truly giving themselves away rather than just talking ourselves into good feelings? I need to be in a place that encourages me to look for a world a lot bigger than the small societal systems of power and prestige.
I feel like as I face what lies before me in the next ten days, everything is going to be totally new again. Totally starting over. I would be lying if I said I am not afraid. I think the reality is that I am petrified. Everything feels so far away and I think part of me fears I won't know how to break back in. I don't fit into the same holes that I left, that's for sure. And I feel like the choice not to settle for security is being challenged yet again as have to say no to some of the old things I once let take my life. Moving away didn't sever all the ties and now the choice is really really mine. What will I do?
The truth is that I have no idea how things will taste to my mouth and feel to my fingers when I get back. I fear being disappointed. I fear everything will loose its color. And the thought of all the new starts exhaust me more than excite me. And I feel as though in so many ways I am walking in all alone. I need someone to hold the rope and I don't know what the rope even looks like.
oh yeah, I was writing about church. What is church? I don't know, but it has to be a lot bigger than just getting together with a few hundred people each week to go through a set of steps. The thing I want is not the same organized facade and to be really honest, the thing I do not want is to be a part of something that requires working really hard to make something work that just leaves me feeling stupid, unarticulate and trapped in my own little world that no one seems to understand. I don't want to waste my time on acting like a faceless challenge-lacking doesn't hurt, doesn't sap my energy to no end.
I think the thing I am really seeking is a group of people that are really working on being real and challenging each other to die a little each day to really live. I don't want to try to fit into some mold a group is trying to fit into in order to maintain valid, "church" status. I'm not interested in that. Maybe I'm being a little too harsh, having too high of expectations. But there is something in me that just doesn't want to take it anymore.
The more I think about it, I think church actually needs to be a lot smaller. We've barricaded ourselves into these fortresses where "us and them" become par for the course. Christianese is our language of choice and it dulls like a drug. We've forgotten about the Jesus who "had no place to lay his head." He wasn't tied down to buildings and preoccupations with food or dress or temples. He simply let go of things so that he could be available to those he came to rescue.
Today at work, I was thinking about how I was raised to label people like my co-workers. As a youth group regular, I was told that the thing that sets me apart from the world is that I act better. We are called, the youth pastor said, to be set apart in our actions so that our classmates don't write us off as hypocrites. So we just wrote them off as sinners. The untouchables. The
secular, separated from us, the
spiritual. And for some reason, that sort of education led me into this fear, like if I got too close, I might catch a disease. That I couldn't really associate with coworkers, classmates until they started cleaning up their acts. It led to this inability to relate.
To paraphrase myself from a few posts ago, I find it very sad and blasphemous that it seems that in the church as I have known it, teaching people how to relate to others doesn't seem like the top priority. It's like we've jumped the gun and started separating the sheep and goats by ourselves before the right time. So I looked at my coworker this afternoon and wondered what to do with her "sin." I reflected on how long my mind has cultivated this wall that maintained that "non-christians" (I shudder at the terrible label as I type it) are quite untouchable indeed.
Don't get involved in their lives. It's a mess. I am beginning to see that this is maybe the point.
A few days ago, I was thinking through what it is that we are really called to invite people into. If our job isn't to go around telling people how bad they are, that they need to start voting-- er believing they way we do, how is God trying to break into the world through our bodies? The only thing I could think of was to somehow communicate forgiveness. Compassion. The heart of a God who is ultimately good and primitively loving.
I have often talked about my experiences at work. The thing is this-- I don't really like to go around talking about my "spiritual interests." "Being Religious" is what my friends at work would call it. I'm not all that excited to reveal that because I know that such a label carries with it all sorts of connotations and hurts and counter-labels. Assumptions about "religious people." In some circles, that would probably be considered being "ashamed of the gospel," but the reality is that I think it is more accurately classified as being ashamed of the way the gospel has become so twisted.
But here is the thing that has brought me so much life: spending so much time with other people who have different experiences than me gives me the opportunity to discover what love and compassion are like when given away. I have an outlet for a lot of the love that I have. I have an opportunity to be forgiving, brief moments to tell people that there is hope and that they are lovely and good and worthy of the dignity that so much of the "religious" world can't seem to afford. To be honest, I have no idea what I communicate for the most part, but I can only hope that the Father has built something into me that comes out naturally. Being myself is really the best thing I can do.